Skip to main content

Builder Comparison

Aston Homes vs Carlisle Homes

Aston Homes and Carlisle Homes are both popular choices for new home builders. But how do their inclusions actually compare? This page breaks down every standard inclusion, common upgrade, and key difference so you can make a fully informed decision.

✓ Independent & unbiased•✓ No builder affiliation•✓ Free to use

How to Compare Aston Homes vs Carlisle Homes Fairly

Comparing two builders purely on advertised price is one of the most common mistakes buyers make. A builder with a lower base price may actually cost more once you add the upgrades required to match another builder's standard inclusions — things like ducted air conditioning, hybrid timber flooring, stone benchtops, or a tiled alfresco. The comparison table shows published inclusion differences; it does not calculate final build prices. Confirm actual costs and specifications with both builders.

What inclusions matter most? Focus on items that significantly affect liveability and upgrade cost: ceiling height, flooring specification, air conditioning type, kitchen appliance grade, stone benchtop thickness, and outdoor inclusions (driveway, fencing, alfresco). These are the features most likely to be listed as upgrades by one builder but included as standard by another.

Check site-cost allowances. Site costs may be included, excluded or handled through allowances, depending on the package and contract. They depend on earthworks, engineering and connections. Any general cost figures are indicative estimates only. Always request current, written site-specific cost estimates from both builders before signing.

Questions to ask both builders: Is the price fixed or does it include provisional sums? What soil class is the slab designed to? Is ducted air conditioning included or an upgrade? Are the driveway, fencing, and landscaping in the contract? What is the NatHERS energy rating? What does the structural warranty cover and for how long? Getting answers in writing — not just verbally at a display home — is the only way to compare fairly.

Key Differences

These inclusions differ between Aston Homes and Carlisle Homes — the areas most worth scrutinising before signing.

InclusionAston HomesCarlisle Homes
2550mm+ Ceiling HeightUpgradeIncluded
DishwasherUpgradeIncluded
Undermount SinkUpgradeIncluded
Shower Niche/sUpgradeIncluded
Freestanding BathtubIncludedUpgrade

Full Inclusions Comparison

Every tracked inclusion for Aston Homes and Carlisle Homes, grouped by category.

PricingAston HomesCarlisle Homes
Site CostsIncludedProvisional
Contract TypeUnknownFixed
Retaining WallsUpgradeUpgrade
Structure & SpecsAston HomesCarlisle Homes
Frame MaterialMGP 10 Timber frame constructionTimber frame construction
2550mm+ Ceiling HeightDIFFUpgrade2740mm Ceilings
Roof MaterialConcrete tilesSteel OR Concrete Tiles
Concrete Slab Grade'H1' Grade'H' Class
Comfort & ClimateAston HomesCarlisle Homes
Ducted Air ConditioningGas ducted heating ONLYGas Ducted Heating
Split SystemUpgradeUpgrade
Ceiling FansUpgradeUpgrade
Kitchen & AppliancesAston HomesCarlisle Homes
Stone Benchtop - KitchenIncludedIncluded
Stone Island BenchtopIncludedIncluded
900mm Kitchen AppliancesIncludedIncluded
DishwasherDIFFUpgradeIncluded
Undermount SinkDIFFUpgradeIncluded
Tap to fridgeUpgradeUpgrade
Soft Close CabinetryIncludedIncluded
Bathroom FinishesAston HomesCarlisle Homes
Shower Niche/sDIFFUpgradeMain ensuite ONLY
Semi Frameless Shower ScreenDIFFUpgradeIncluded
Freestanding BathtubDIFFIncludedUpgrade
LaundryAston HomesCarlisle Homes
Laundry CabinetIncludedIncluded
Stone benchtop - LaundryIncludedIncluded
Outdoor & ExternalAston HomesCarlisle Homes
DrivewayUpgradeUpgrade
Tiled AlfrescoUpgradeUpgrade
LandscapingUpgradeUpgrade
1200mm Entry DoorUpgradeUpgrade
Energy EfficiencyAston HomesCarlisle Homes
Energy Star Rating7 Star7 Star
InsulationIncludedIncluded
Solar2.64kw system (design specific)3.5kw System
EV ChargerUpgradeUpgrade
FlooringAston HomesCarlisle Homes
FlooringLaminate, Tiles + CarpetLaminate, Tiles + Carpet
WarrantyAston HomesCarlisle Homes
Structural Warranty30 year structural guarantee25 Year Structural Guarantee
Maintenance Warranty6 months90 days

Which Builder May Suit You?

A quick guide to help narrow down your decision between Aston Homes and Carlisle Homes.

Aston Homes may suit you if...

  • You've compared Aston Homes's standard inclusions above and they match more of what you want than Carlisle Homes.

Carlisle Homes may suit you if...

  • You've compared Carlisle Homes's standard inclusions above and they match more of what you want than Aston Homes.

Overall Comparison Summary

Aston Homes and Carlisle Homes differ on 6 tracked inclusions — from ceiling height to flooring, air conditioning and outdoor finishes. Neither builder is objectively "better"; the right choice depends on which standard inclusions matter most to you and which upgrades you're happy to pay for. Use the tables above to weigh up the real cost difference, not just the advertised starting price.

Compare Aston Homes & Carlisle Homes in Your Area

Choose your build location to confirm both builders service it, then compare their inclusions side-by-side.

Start Comparing

Frequently Asked Questions